Home / EMP corner / Do faraday bags actually work?
Do faraday bags actually work? (2026)
By Power and Pantry. Lab reports, guidance documents, and prices checked November 2026.
Disclosure: Power and Pantry is reader supported. If a link on this page earns a commission in the future, it will be marked, and it never changes a comparison. The verdicts here follow published lab reports, government guidance, and arithmetic, not commissions.
Short answer, in the two parts the product pages blur together. For signal blocking, yes: a well-made faraday bag, sealed the way its maker instructs, cuts cellular, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, and GPS signals to a phone or key fob inside by amounts that are measured in laboratories and that you can check yourself with a phone call. For EMP protection, no consumer bag carries proof: no bag has been tested against an actual EMP waveform, and the US government's own protection guidelines, which do recommend foil wrap and Faraday containers for spare electronics, state on every page that they do not endorse any product. What those guidelines actually recommend is in the EMP section below, and it is cheaper and calmer than the marketing suggests.
How to read this page. Every shielding figure is labeled with whose number it is: a maker's published lab result, with the lab and the test standard named, or a government document, with the agency named. Nothing on this page is presented as tested by us, because none of it was. Where a maker's headline number and a maker's own lab report disagree, both are printed.
How shielding works, in plain terms
A faraday bag is a flexible version of the faraday cage: a closed shell of conductive material, in practice a fabric woven or coated with metal, with the device inside it. Radio waves reaching the shell drive small currents in the conductive layer, and those currents cancel the field on the inside. The device sits in the quiet space the shell creates. The physics needs exactly one thing: the shell has to be continuous. A gap in the shell is a door in the cage, and radio energy uses doors.
That is why the closure is the whole product. Seams are sewn or bonded runs of the same conductive material; the opening is the one place the shell has to open and close again, so makers close it with a double roll and a seal, or a magnetic flap, that presses conductive surface against conductive surface across the full width. Mission Darkness prints the failure mode on its own product page: a cable, a strap, or a corner of fabric caught in the closure will let signals pass through. A bag sealed carelessly is a bag with a hole in it, whatever its fabric tested at.
Shielding is measured in decibels (dB), and the scale is logarithmic, which makes small-looking differences large. The DHS guidelines include a decibel table (their Table E-1), and the power figures from it are: 20 dB of attenuation means the signal power getting through is cut by a factor of 100; 40 dB, by a factor of 10,000; 60 dB, by a factor of 1,000,000; 80 dB, by a factor of 100,000,000. A phone needs only a faint thread of signal to stay connected, which is why bags are built to high numbers, and why a leak at the closure, which can cost most of those numbers at one spot, matters more than the difference between one good fabric and another.
Question one: do they block signals?
Yes, and this half of the claim is ordinary, checkable engineering. The two serious brands in the category publish independent lab results, summarized in the table in the next section. The signals a sealed bag has to stop are known and named: cellular bands including 5G, Wi-Fi at 2.4 and 5 GHz, Bluetooth, GPS, and the low-frequency radio that key fobs and access cards use. A bag that attenuates those bands by the published amounts leaves a phone inside it with nothing to connect to.
The honest caveat comes from the National Institute of Standards and Technology. NIST's Guidelines on Mobile Device Forensics (SP 800-101 Revision 1), written for investigators who bag seized phones for a living, state that Faraday containers "may attenuate the radio signal, but not necessarily eliminate it completely," and that a phone can still reach a cell tower if it is in the tower's immediate vicinity. The same passage names the practical risk: a container improperly sealed. Attenuation is a ratio, not a wall, and a very strong nearby signal against a badly sealed bag can still get a thread through. NIST also notes that a phone isolated from the network raises its transmit power to maximum while it searches, which drains its battery faster, a small fact worth knowing before you store a phone in a bag for a week.
The test you can run yourself
Put your phone in the bag, seal it exactly as the maker instructs, and call the phone from another phone. A working bag means the call does not ring through; it goes to voicemail or reports the phone unreachable. Take the phone out and it should show it has been off the network. The Department of Homeland Security's guidelines prescribe the same test for a microwave oven used as an expedient cage: test it with a cell phone and an AM/FM radio to see whether there is reception inside. Run the test again whenever you want to know whether the bag still works, because the test checks the whole product, fabric, seams, and your sealing of it, in a way no lab report on a fabric sample can. What the test proves is signal blocking, in your house, today. It proves nothing about an EMP, and the next sections keep that line bright.
The one everyday use with a clear mechanism: key fobs
A passive-entry key fob is always listening for its car's low-frequency query, and it answers with a radio credential. A relay attack puts one device near the fob, by a front door, say, and a second device at the car, and relays the query and the answer across the distance, so the car concludes the fob is beside it when the fob is in the house. A fob sealed in a shielding pouch cannot hear the query and cannot answer it, so the relay has nothing to carry. That is the whole mechanism, and it works while the fob is stored in the pouch, which is the only claim worth making for it. SLNT, one of the makers below, notes that most North American fobs answer on 315 MHz and European, Japanese, and Asian fobs on 433.92 MHz, both far below the cellular bands and both inside the range its material is tested over.
What the lab numbers do and do not establish
Two test standards stand behind nearly every serious claim in this category, and each one needs its scope stated.
IEEE 299-2006 is, by its title in the DHS guidelines' own reference list, the "Standard Method for Measuring the Effectiveness of Electromagnetic Shielding Enclosures." It is a measurement method: it says how to measure how much a continuous radio signal is reduced across an enclosure, frequency by frequency. A result under IEEE 299 is a real measurement of shielding against radio signals. It is not a test against a pulse.
MIL-STD-188-125 is the military's high-altitude EMP protection standard, and its full title, also from the guidelines' references, is "High-Altitude Electromagnetic Pulse (HEMP) Protection for Ground-Based C4I Facilities." It was written for fixed facilities: buildings with shielded entryways, protected cable penetrations, and a maintenance program that re-verifies the shield over its life. When a bag maker says its fabric was tested to MIL-STD-188-125, the accurate reading is that a lab measured the material's shielding effectiveness against levels drawn from that standard. The fabric can pass those levels. The bag is not, and cannot be, a certified facility, and a shielding measurement made with steady radio signals is not an exposure to an EMP waveform.
The table below prints what each maker actually publishes, including the difference between the two brands on a point most roundups miss: whether the lab tested the finished product or the material it is cut from.
| Product | Published lab basis (maker-published results) | Price at the maker's own store, November 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Mission Darkness Non-Window Faraday Bag for Phones (MOS Equipment). Two layers of TitanRF fabric, double roll and Velcro closure, 8.5 by 5 inch interior. | Keystone Compliance, an independent compliance laboratory, tested Mission Darkness finished products and materials against MIL-STD-188-125-2 and IEEE 299-2006. MOS publishes 80+ dB of attenuation from low MHz to 40 GHz, with per-band minimums of 85 dB (Wi-Fi 2.4 GHz), 83 dB (Wi-Fi 5 GHz), 82 dB (cellular LTE), 80 dB (5G), 85 dB (Bluetooth), and 84 dB (GPS). | $23, shown as a sale price when checked |
| Mission Darkness Dry Shield Faraday Tote 7L (MOS Equipment). A 7-liter weatherproof dry-bag style tote for several devices at once. | Built from the same TitanRF fabric, so the same Keystone Compliance results against MIL-STD-188-125-2 and IEEE 299-2006 stand behind it: 80+ dB across the published range. | $55 |
| SLNT Faraday Phone Sleeve (Silent Pocket). A phone sleeve in weatherproof nylon; Medium Plus and leather versions cost more. | SLNT states on the product page that the lab results are for its Multishield material, tested by Keystone Compliance, and "are not a test of the finished sleeve." The reports it cites: MIL-STD-188-125-2, 10 kHz to 1 GHz, double- and triple-layer material samples reported compliant (Report 2106-125EB, 2021); and the IEEE 299-2006 method, 1 to 40 GHz, a single layer of the material measuring 79.8 to 94.9 dB (Report 2203-117EB-2, 2022). SLNT's headline pages elsewhere claim "100 dB+" blocking; the range with a report number behind it is the 79.8 to 94.9 dB above. | $79.95 list for the Medium in nylon ($63.96 during the maker's Black Friday sale running when checked); Medium Plus $89.95; leather $99.95 |
Read the table the way the site's other comparisons are read: the numbers are real, they are the makers' published lab results rather than our measurements, and they establish signal blocking. The calibration from the government's side is worth holding next to them. In the DHS guidelines, the entry protection level (Level 1) stores spare electronics in an area with at least 20 dB of protection, a factor of 100 in power, and the highest level (Level 4), built on MIL-STD-188-125-1 for facilities that cannot tolerate seconds of outage, calls for 80+ dB through 10 GHz as one element of a program that also includes protected entryways, surge devices on every penetrating cable, and scheduled re-testing of the shield. The number 80 dB appears in both worlds. In one it is a fabric measurement on a pouch. In the other it is a maintained building. Keeping those two meanings separate is most of what honest coverage of this category consists of.
Placeholder: matched offers
When this site's affiliate programs are approved, this block will show the phone bag, the tote, and the sleeve from this page, with dated prices.
No affiliate links are live on this page yet, and nothing here is a product endorsement.
Question two: what about an EMP?
An EMP from a high-altitude nuclear burst (HEMP) is not one pulse but three components, and the DHS guidelines' structure for them is the clearest public description available.
- E1, the fast component. The guidelines' comparison table gives it a duration of less than a microsecond and a high peak field with a quick rise time. E1 is the component that threatens electronics and control systems directly, because it rises faster than surge protectors react.
- E2, the intermediate component. The guidelines treat E2 alongside lightning: it resembles a lightning strike's electrical environment, and they note that precautions taken against E1 generally cover E2 as well, which is why their document gives it less attention.
- E3, the slow component. Lasting seconds to minutes in its blast and heave phases, E3 couples into long conductors. The equipment at risk in the guidelines' table is transformers and protective relays on long transmission lines. E3 is a threat to the grid through its wires, not to a device sitting on a shelf.
The coupling point is the one the whole category's marketing skips. The guidelines state it in one sentence: "The primary issue is that cables act as antennas to conduct EMP energy to unprotected equipment." They continue: "small electronics without cables, such as cell phones and land mobile radios, are relatively resilient to EMP, their supporting infrastructures are not," and small devices are at risk particularly if they are turned on or charging when the pulse arrives. In the guidelines' Level 1 detail, the same point is made about handheld electronics: "relatively immune to EMP effects, unless they have long antennas or power cords attached, and so the need for Faraday cages is of secondary importance." Secondary importance is the government's own ranking, in its own document, for the exact devices the bags are sold to protect.
What the government actually recommends for spares
The document is the Electromagnetic Pulse (EMP) Protection and Resilience Guidelines for Critical Infrastructure and Equipment, Version 2.2, February 5, 2019, developed by the National Coordinating Center for Communications under the Department of Homeland Security and published through CISA. It was written for officials and infrastructure operators, in four protection levels. Its lowest-cost level, Level 1, is the one that speaks to a household's spare electronics, and its advice is short:
- Unplug power, data, and antenna lines from spare or backup equipment where feasible, disconnecting at the equipment rather than only at the wall, because an attached cord still acts as an antenna. Turn off equipment that cannot be unplugged. Remove battery packs from small electronics where they come out.
- "Wrap spare electronics with aluminum foil or put in Faraday containers." The detail section specifies heavy-duty foil over a plastic or paper insulating bag, seams overlapped, two or more complete layers if possible, and adds the caution that a Faraday bag should not be "just a standard Mylar food bag which provides little protection."
- Keep at least a lightning-rated surge protection device on anything that stays connected, and keep spares of the protectors.
Two things about that advice deserve emphasis. First, the guidelines name no consumer brand, and every page of the document carries the note that the guidelines "do not endorse any referenced product, company, service, or information external to DHS." Any seller implying a government endorsement of its bag is claiming something the government's document expressly refuses to give. Second, the recommended container sits next to kitchen foil as an equal option. A purpose-made bag is tidier, reusable, and published with lab numbers for its signal blocking. The government document does not rank it above two careful layers of heavy-duty foil for the spare-electronics job, because for that job the requirement it sets is modest: an area or container with at least 20 dB of protection for stored spares.
The scope of what any bag can do
A bag protects the thing inside it, at the moment of the event, if the thing inside is off, unplugged, and sealed in. It does not protect the grid, the cell towers, the water system, or anything plugged into a wall, and it does not keep the network your phone needs alive on the other end. Read against the guidelines, the realistic protected kit is small and specific: a spare battery radio of the kind the guidelines themselves build their alert plan around, a drive holding documents and photos, a backup phone, the radios a household actually uses to talk to each other. It is an inexpensive kit precisely because it is small, and a bag or a foil wrap covers it for the price of a pizza. Spending beyond that kit is not buying more protection. It is buying more bag.
Buying one, for the job it provably does
If you want a bag for signal blocking, for a fob by the door, a phone that goes properly dark, or a tidy reusable container for spares, the buying rules follow from the evidence above.
Look for:
- Published lab results with a named laboratory and a named standard, and a sentence you can find that says what was tested: the finished product, or the material. Both brands in the table name Keystone Compliance and publish report-level detail; that is the category's high-water mark, and a seller offering neither a lab nor a report is asking to be taken on faith.
- A closure that presses conductive surface together across the full opening, like the double roll on the Mission Darkness bags, and instructions for sealing it that you will actually follow every time.
- Two layers of shielding fabric rather than one, which both brands in the table build with, and per-band numbers rather than a single average, so you can see the weakest band instead of the best one.
Ignore:
- "EMP proof" as an unqualified claim. No consumer product has been exposed to an EMP waveform in a test you can read, and the phrase has no standard behind it.
- "Military grade" as a bare adjective. The military standard in this category, MIL-STD-188-125, is a standard for fixed facilities; a fabric measured against its shielding levels has earned a sentence about a lab measurement, not a rank.
- A headline decibel figure with no lab, no standard, and no report behind it, including a round "100 dB+" where the same maker's published lab range for its material tops out lower.
On price, the table above is the honest spread for November 2026: $23 for the lab-tested phone bag, $55 for the tote that holds a family's small devices, $79.95 and up for the sleeve whose maker publishes its material results with unusual candor about what they cover. The signal job does not require the top of that range. It requires a sealed shell and a phone test that passes.
Questions people actually ask
Does a faraday bag protect against a solar flare?
The question mixes two different events, and the DHS guidelines' comparison table separates them. A geomagnetic disturbance (GMD), the grid-relevant effect of a major solar storm, has, in the table's words, "No comparable E1 wave forms" and "No comparable E2 wave forms." What a solar storm produces is the slow, E3-like component: fluctuating fields lasting hours, coupling into long conductors, with transformers and protective relays on long transmission lines as the equipment at risk. A phone on a shelf is not a long conductor, and there is no fast pulse for a bag to stop. In a severe solar storm the thing at risk is the power grid and everything that depends on it staying up, which is an outage problem, the subject of the rest of this site, and not a shielding problem. A bag neither helps nor is needed for the device itself.
Will it protect my car?
No. The car is not inside the bag, and a bag sized for a car is a building project, not a product. Whether a modern vehicle's electronics would be damaged by an EMP is a separate question with its own literature, and this page takes no position on it beyond noting that the guidelines' coupling point applies at vehicle scale too: connected cables and wiring are the paths in. The one car-related job a small bag does provably do is the key fob's, described above.
Does the bag need to be grounded?
No. Shielding by enclosure works because the closed conductive shell carries the currents on its own surface; no wire to earth is part of the mechanism, and a floating enclosure shields. Nothing in the DHS guidelines' foil, container, or microwave advice includes a grounding step, and their fix for a metal trash can, below, is about sealing gaps, not adding a ground. Grounding matters for the surge protectors and facility shields elsewhere in those guidelines, where conducted energy needs somewhere to go. A pouch has no conducted path to manage. It has a shell to keep closed.
Do faraday bags wear out?
The materials can be damaged, and the closure is a wear item by design. Mission Darkness's own care instructions are to avoid punctures and sharp objects and to keep anything from crossing the seal. A roll-and-press closure handled daily will not seal at year three the way it did when new, and conductive fabric that has been punctured has a hole in the shell whether or not the hole is easy to see. There is no expiry date to print here, because the makers do not publish one. The practical answer is the phone test from the signal section: run it when the bag is new, so you know what a pass looks like, and run it again whenever you are about to rely on the bag. A bag that fails the test has told you everything an expiry date would.
Can I use a metal trash can instead?
The guidelines answer this one directly, and the answer is: not as it comes from the store. "Metal trash cans do not usually provide reliable EMP protection for items placed inside of them, unless they have been modified to block radio waves from entering through the gaps in the lid, handles, and sometimes at the base." The can is a shell with doors in it, at the lid rim, the handle rivets, and the base seam, and the modification the guidelines describe is closing those gaps so the shell is continuous. Their own first recommendation for spares is simpler than the modified can: the device in an insulating bag, wrapped in two or more complete layers of heavy-duty aluminum foil with the seams overlapped. The same passage offers one more expedient enclosure: a microwave oven "can serve as expedient Faraday cages for small electronics," tested with a phone or radio for reception inside, and never turned on with equipment inside. Whichever enclosure you use, the phone test is how you know.
Is a mylar food bag the same thing?
No, and the guidelines say so in the sentence quoted above: a Faraday bag should not be "just a standard Mylar food bag which provides little protection." The metallized film on a food storage bag is far thinner than the conductive fabric in a tested shielding bag, it is not built or sewn as a continuous enclosure, and it carries no lab results. The resemblance is visual only.
Data basis for this page: the Electromagnetic Pulse (EMP) Protection and Resilience Guidelines for Critical Infrastructure and Equipment, Version 2.2, February 5, 2019, developed by the National Coordinating Center for Communications (DHS) and published through CISA (the Level 1 recommendations and their detail on unplugging, foil, Faraday containers, trash cans, and microwave ovens; the section 1.4 statement on cables and small electronics; Table 3, the HEMP and GMD comparison adapted there from the US Department of Energy's Electromagnetic Pulse Resilience Action Plan; Table E-1, the decibel table; and the reference-list titles of MIL-STD-188-125-1 and IEEE Std 299-2006); NIST Special Publication 800-101 Revision 1, Guidelines on Mobile Device Forensics (the attenuation caveat, the improper-sealing risk, and the battery drain of radio-isolated phones); MOS Equipment's Mission Darkness testing page and product pages (Keystone Compliance as the testing laboratory, MIL-STD-188-125-2 and IEEE 299-2006 as the standards, 80+ dB with per-band minimums, the sealing and care instructions, and the $23 phone bag and $55 7L tote prices), checked November 2026; and SLNT's Faraday Phone Sleeve product page (the statement that its lab results cover the Multishield material and not the finished sleeve, Keystone Compliance Reports 2106-125EB and 2203-117EB-2 with their ranges and the 79.8 to 94.9 dB single-layer result, the fob frequency note, and the $79.95 to $99.95 prices), checked November 2026. Prices and lab pages will drift; the guidelines' ranking of the problem will not. Related reading on this site: the companion explainer faraday cage vs faraday bag, which compares this page's bags with cages, cabinets, and shielded rooms; the blackout power pillar, where the outage side of every scenario on this page is worked through with the same sourced-numbers rule; and the problem grid on our home page.