Affiliate disclosure: Power and Pantry is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from the seller, at no extra cost to you. Commissions never change the math below. Full policy on our About page.
Filter straws and portable purification, compared (2026)
By the Power and Pantry editors. Specifications and prices checked at the makers' own stores, product pages, manuals, and warranty pages in November 2026, and treatment guidance at the CDC's emergency and travel water pages. Prices and stock move; the figures below are dated so you can recheck them.
The short answer
This category is sold under the word purification, and the first job of this page is to narrow that word back down to what the products in it actually do. Four findings run the comparison:
- Not one of the five membrane filters here removes viruses, and the makers say so themselves. LifeStraw's FAQ for its Peak straw states: "It does not filter chemicals, heavy metals, or dissolved minerals," and LifeStraw's FAQ for the squeeze bottle built on the same membrane says it does not remove viruses or heavy metals like lead. Sawyer states it on its Duo page, about its squeeze filter line: "It does not remove viruses, dissolved chemicals, salt, or heavy metals." The CDC's emergency water page is blunter: "Portable water filters do not remove all types of germs from water. Portable filters: Will not remove viruses." Only two entries in this grid address viruses at all: the GRAYL press bottle, which GRAYL says meets the EPA's purifier standard, and chlorine dioxide tablets. The category name describes two of its seven products.
- A wetted hollow-fiber filter that freezes can be ruined silently, and the makers' warranty and manual pages say so in capital letters and plain warnings. Sawyer's warranty page answers the question directly: a filter that froze after wetting should be replaced, there is no way to know whether the fibers were damaged, the test costs more than the filter, and the page closes the section with "THERE IS NO WARRANTY FOR A FROZEN FILTER." A filter that has never been wetted is unharmed by freezing; once water is introduced, Sawyer says, it never completely dries out. Katadyn's BeFree manual carries the same warning from the other side: "Do not use in freezing conditions, as a frozen EZ-Clean Membrane can lead to bypass and illness." A kit that lives in a cold car or an unheated garage carries an expiry condition no product listing prints.
- Rated filter lives in this grid run from 264 gallons to 100,000 gallons, a spread of about 380 to 1, and the biggest number is the softest. The 100,000-gallon figure belongs to Sawyer's MINI, stated on its product page and Sawyer's warranty page. For the larger Sawyer Squeeze, Sawyer's own product page prints no gallon figure at all, only a lifetime limited warranty; the 100,000-gallon figure for that filter lives in Sawyer's bundle pages. Both Sawyer ratings assume the filter is backflushed with the included syringe as it slows. LifeStraw's ratings end physically instead: its filters stop allowing flow at the end of their rated life.
- A straw cannot fill a container. A straw treats water at the source, one sip at a time, for one person standing at the water. The squeeze formats in this grid can fill bottles and cooking pots, which is what makes them, and not straws, the portable tier that connects to a household problem. Even they work in liters. The household-scale answers on this site stay where they were: stored water, containers to hold it, and gravity filtration for volume.
How this comparison was put together
Every specification on this page comes from the makers' own stores, product pages, published manuals, and warranty pages, checked in November 2026, and the treatment rules come from the CDC. Prices are the makers' own store prices where the maker sells direct, which covers LifeStraw, Sawyer, and GRAYL. Katadyn sells through dealers in the United States and publishes no US store price we could verify, so Katadyn prices below are labeled retailer prices, checked in November 2026. Cost per gallon is our own arithmetic on the makers' rated lives, and a rated life is a maker's figure under the maker's conditions, not a field result. We did not drink through, freeze, or flow-test any product on this page, and no figure here is presented as a bench result.
Two contradictions inside the makers' own materials are printed on this page rather than smoothed over, because both change what a buyer thinks they are getting. The first is the Sawyer Squeeze's missing gallon rating, covered above and in its section below. The second is smaller: LifeStraw's page for its 1L squeeze bottle carries one specification block naming a 650 ml bottle in its includes line and another naming the 1L; the product sold on that page is the 1L, and this page uses the 1L figures. Stock notes, dated November 2026: the Peak straw showed out of stock at LifeStraw's store for the variant checked, and the replacement membrane for the LifeStraw squeeze bottle showed sold out on its product page when checked.
What portable purification actually removes
The CDC's framework settles most of the category before any brand is named. To remove bacteria, the CDC says, a portable filter must have an absolute pore size of 0.3 micron or smaller; to remove parasites such as Giardia and Cryptosporidium, an absolute pore size of 1 micron or smaller. Every membrane product in this grid is rated at 0.1 or 0.2 micron absolute, so their bacteria and protozoa figures line up with the CDC's framework. Viruses are smaller than any pore in this grid and pass through a membrane filter, which is why no membrane product here claims them, and why the CDC says portable filters will not remove viruses, full stop.
Chemicals and metals sit on the other side of the same line. A membrane stops particles; dissolved chemicals, heavy metals, and salt are not particles, and the makers' own exclusions above say exactly that. The exceptions in this grid are partial and specific. GRAYL's cartridge pairs its electroadsorption media with ultra-powdered activated carbon, and GRAYL says the carbon adsorbs many chemicals, including PFAS and VOCs, plus pesticides, herbicides, and heavy metals; GRAYL also publishes its own exclusions, stating the cartridge is not designed for industrial disasters, coal ash spills, very high lead levels, mercury, nuclear disasters, high tannin concentrations, or water with toxic blue-green algae. LifeStraw sells a separate activated carbon attachment for its squeeze line at $14.95; the membrane's own exclusions, stated in LifeStraw's FAQs, stand either way.
The word purifier has a definition, and this site used it in the gravity filter comparison: a purifier is held to the EPA's guide standard for microbiological water purifiers, which includes virus removal, and a filter is not. Two entries here meet that bar by their makers' accounts. GRAYL states the GeoPress was independently tested to meet or exceed NSF/ANSI protocols 42 and 53 and meets the EPA's guide standard and protocol for testing microbiological water purifiers. Katadyn describes its Micropur MP1 tablets as the only product of their kind EPA-registered as a microbiological water purifier. Everything else in the grid is a filter, whatever a marketplace headline calls it.
The CDC's recommended method is a sequence, not a product: boiling is the best way to kill germs in water, and where boiling is not possible, filter the water and then disinfect it, because the disinfectant kills the viruses and bacteria the filter leaves behind. The CDC also cautions that chemical disinfectants may not kill parasites including Cryptosporidium and Giardia, and do not work as well as boiling against them. That caution sits next to Katadyn's own tablet directions in the Micropur section below, and both are printed as their sources state them; the package label in your hand governs the product you own. One more CDC line bounds the whole category: water containing fuel, toxic chemicals, or radioactive materials cannot be made safe by boiling or disinfecting it, and nothing in this grid changes that.
The seven products, side by side
| Product | Format | Method | Removes, per the maker | Does not remove | Rated life | Price, checked November 2026 | Replacement | Cost per rated gallon (computed) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LifeStraw Peak Series Straw | Straw | 0.2 micron membrane | Bacteria 99.999999%, parasites 99.999%, microplastics, silt and sand | Viruses, chemicals, heavy metals, dissolved minerals (maker's FAQ) | Up to 1,000 gal | $24.95 at LifeStraw's store | None. The straw is the filter; the unit is replaced whole | About 2.5 cents |
| Sawyer MINI | Squeeze filter | 0.1 micron absolute hollow fiber | Bacteria 99.99999%, protozoa 99.9999%, microplastics 100% | Viruses, dissolved chemicals, salt, heavy metals (maker) | Up to 100,000 gal (maker rating) | $28.99 at Sawyer's store | Backflushed with the included syringe, not replaced on a schedule | About 0.03 cents at the maker's rating |
| Sawyer Squeeze | Squeeze filter, larger kit | 0.1 micron absolute hollow fiber | Same figures as the MINI (maker; independent lab report S05-03) | Viruses, dissolved chemicals, salt, heavy metals (maker) | No gallon figure on Sawyer's product page; lifetime limited warranty. Sawyer's bundle pages say up to 100,000 gal | $45.99 at Sawyer's store | Replacement filter listed at $84.95 on the same page | About 0.05 cents at the bundle-page figure |
| LifeStraw Peak Series Collapsible Squeeze 1L | Squeeze bottle | 0.2 micron membrane | Bacteria 99.999999%, parasites 99.999%, microplastics, silt and sand | Viruses and heavy metals like lead (maker's FAQ for the line) | Up to 500 gal (2,000 L) | $43.95 at LifeStraw's store | Membrane filter $17.95; showed sold out when checked | About 8.8 cents; about 3.6 cents on replacement membranes |
| Katadyn BeFree 1.0L | Squeeze flask | 0.1 micron hollow fiber (EZ-Clean Membrane) | Bacteria 99.9999%, protozoan cysts 99.9% (maker's manual) | Viruses, chemicals, heavy metals | Up to 264 gal (1,000 L), depending on water quality (maker) | Not published at Katadyn's US store; $44.95 list at Amazon (retailer price) | Cartridge $29.95 at US retailers | About 17 cents; about 11 cents on replacement cartridges |
| GRAYL GeoPress 24 oz | Press purifier bottle | Electroadsorption plus ultra-powdered activated carbon | Viruses 99.99%, bacteria 99.9999%, protozoan cysts 99.9%; carbon adsorbs many chemicals, pesticides, herbicides, heavy metals | Salt; high-level chemical contamination (maker's own exclusions) | 350 cycles, 65 gal per cartridge | $89.95 at GRAYL's store; retailers list $99.95 | Purifier cartridge $29.95 | About $1.38 on the first cartridge; about 46 cents on replacements |
| Katadyn Micropur MP1 | Chemical tablets | Chlorine dioxide | Viruses and bacteria in 15 minutes; Giardia and Cryptosporidium per Katadyn's directions, 30 minutes in clear water, 4 hours in worst-case water | Particulates, chemicals, metals, salt. A tablet filters nothing out | 30 liters per 30-tablet pack | About $18.95 for 30 tablets at US retailers (retailer price) | Each pack is the consumable | About 63 cents per liter; about $2.39 per gallon |
Three rating conditions belong under this grid. Sawyer's ratings assume backflushing: Sawyer's page for its Dual Threaded MINI states that backwashing with the included syringe restores up to 98.5 percent of the filter's flow rate, and a filter that is never backflushed slows long before any gallon figure arrives. Katadyn rates the BeFree at up to 1,000 liters "depending on water quality," its own qualifier, printed in its manual. GRAYL's cartridge announces its own end: the press time climbs as the cartridge loads, and GRAYL's instruction is to replace it when a press takes about 25 seconds, or three years after first use.
Matched offers (placeholder). When this site's affiliate programs are approved, this block will list the products above at the sellers we link to, with prices rechecked at posting. Until then there are no purchase links on this page, and the prices in the grid are the makers' own published prices, or labeled retailer prices, from November 2026. Portable filters treat drinking water in liters; if the open question is how much water your household needs in gallons, the water storage calculator turns people and days into gallons and a container plan.
The straw: LifeStraw Peak Series Straw
The Peak Series Straw is the product the category is named after: a 0.2 micron membrane in a tube 1.26 by 7.7 inches, 2.3 ounces, that you drink through directly at a source. LifeStraw rates it at up to 1,000 gallons and states that it meets US EPA and NSF P231 drinking water standards for the removal of bacteria and parasites. It has no replaceable filter; the straw is the filter, and LifeStraw states the membrane stops allowing flow when it reaches the end of its life, which makes the rating self-enforcing in a way a backflushed filter's rating is not. Unused, it has an unlimited shelf life by LifeStraw's account, the one storage figure in this grid with no clock on it at all.
Its limits are the category's limits in their purest form. It treats water only in the act of drinking it, so it cannot fill a bottle, a pot, or a child's cup; LifeStraw fits it with a threaded bottom cap that attaches to some 28mm single-use bottles and to gravity hoses, which turns it into a drink-from-a-bottle filter, still one person and one mouthful at a time. LifeStraw's FAQ adds two source limits: it does not work in saltwater or brackish water, and pool water is not recommended. At $24.95 and about 2.5 cents per rated gallon, it is cheap, light, and shelf-stable insurance for one person's drinking water. It is not a household water plan, and nothing in LifeStraw's own copy claims otherwise.
Sawyer MINI: the 100,000-gallon rating and its conditions
The MINI is a 0.1 micron absolute hollow fiber filter, 2 ounces in the field, sold at $28.99 with a 16-ounce reusable pouch, a cleaning syringe, and a straw. It screws onto the pouch, onto standard 28mm disposable bottles, or into hydration-pack tubing, and it can be used with the included straw directly at a source, so unlike the LifeStraw it works in both directions of the portable category: drink through it, or squeeze through it into a container. Sawyer states that 100 percent of its filters are individually tested three times. The removal figures match the Squeeze below, and Sawyer's warranty page rates the MINI, the Dual Threaded MINI, and the Micro Squeeze at up to 100,000 gallons.
The rating's conditions are maintenance and pressure. Flow is restored by backwashing with the included syringe, which Sawyer's Dual Threaded MINI page credits with restoring up to 98.5 percent of flow rate; a MINI that is never backflushed is a slow filter with a large number on its box. And Sawyer's FAQ for the MINI puts a pressure ceiling on the whole line: the filters are designed to handle up to 20 psi, and Sawyer instructs owners not to attach one directly to a spigot or faucet, because higher pressure can damage the fibers. That instruction matters for outage improvisation, where a filter screwed onto a household tap is an obvious idea and, per the maker, a damaging one.
Sawyer Squeeze: the bigger kit, and a rating that lives in the bundle copy
The Squeeze is the same 0.1 micron absolute membrane in a larger, stronger-walled filter, 3 ounces for the filter itself, sold at $45.99 as a kit: two reusable pouches, a cleaning plunger and coupling, gravity tubing, inline hydration pack adapters, and a mesh storage bag. The gravity tubing is the household-relevant item in the box; it lets the filter run as a small gravity feed into a container rather than a hand-squeezed pouch, which is the closest anything in this grid comes to the gravity systems in our gravity comparison, at personal rather than household volume. The removal figures are credited by Sawyer to independent testing laboratory Hydreion, LLC, microbiological report S05-03.
What the Squeeze does not have, on its own product page, is a gallon rating. The longevity line on Sawyer's Squeeze page reads, in full, "Backed by manufacturer's lifetime limited warranty," and the warranty page itself rates the MINI line at 100,000 gallons while giving the Squeeze no figure. The up-to-100,000-gallons figure for the Squeeze appears in Sawyer's bundle pages, paired with Cnoc bottles. This page prints both facts rather than merging them, because the difference is the honest summary of the product: Sawyer warrants the Squeeze filter itself against defects for its life, does not warrant the pouches and accessories, and does not publish a throughput number for it on the page where it is sold. One more figure from that page belongs in the open: Sawyer lists a replacement Squeeze filter at $84.95, which is more than the $45.99 system on the same page. With a lifetime warranty on the filter, replacement is a warranty question before it is a purchase.
LifeStraw Peak Squeeze 1L: the straw's membrane in a bottle that can fill a pot
The squeeze bottle takes the Peak membrane, 0.2 micron, rated to 2,000 liters or 500 gallons, and builds it into a collapsible 1-liter bottle, 3.2 ounces, at $43.95. The format change is the product: LifeStraw states it can be squeezed into cooking containers or other drinkware, used as a straw, or connected to other Peak systems, so it does the one thing the straw cannot, which is produce treated water for something other than the drinker. The removal figures and the EPA and NSF P231 statement match the straw's, and so do the exclusions: LifeStraw's FAQ for the squeeze bottle states the membrane does not remove viruses or heavy metals like lead.
The running costs are the highest among the membrane filters here, and they are printed on LifeStraw's own page. The first 500 gallons cost about 8.8 cents each at the $43.95 bottle price; the replacement membrane filter is $17.95, which brings replacement gallons to about 3.6 cents, and that replacement showed sold out on the product page when checked in November 2026. An activated carbon attachment is offered at $14.95 for the line. None of this makes the bottle a poor buy; it makes it a priced one, in the same way the WaterBrick is priced in our container comparison: you are paying for a format, a soft bottle that packs flat and fills a pot, and the grid above lets you see the price of the format next to the Sawyers' prices for the same job.
Katadyn BeFree 1.0L: the fastest flow, the shortest rating, and a flask only it fits
The BeFree's specification sheet reads like a deliberate trade. Its 0.1 micron EZ-Clean Membrane is rated by Katadyn at 99.9999 percent removal of bacteria and 99.9 percent of protozoan cysts, the cyst figure a step below the 99.9999 percent protozoa claims of the Sawyers and LifeStraws in this grid. Its flow rate is the fastest a maker states here, up to 2 liters per minute. Its rated life is the shortest of the membrane filters, up to 1,000 liters or 264 gallons, with Katadyn's own qualifier that the figure depends on water quality. The whole system, filter and its 1-liter HydraPak flask, weighs 63 grams by Katadyn's manual, about 2.3 ounces, the lightest squeeze system in the grid. Katadyn's US list price is not published where we could verify it; the grid uses the $44.95 list price shown at Amazon, labeled as a retailer price, and the replacement cartridge is $29.95 at US retailers, which puts BeFree water at about 17 cents per rated gallon and replacement gallons at about 11 cents.
Two design decisions bound it. The flask's threads are 42 mm, a size that fits the BeFree's own flask and not the standard 28mm bottles the Sawyers and the LifeStraw straw accept, so the filter and the flask are a pair for life. And the membrane is cleaned by shaking or swishing it in water, with no backflush; when flow has significantly slowed past cleaning, Katadyn's manual directs replacement. The manual also carries the freeze warning quoted at the top of this page, in the strongest wording any maker here uses: a frozen membrane "can lead to bypass and illness." A shelf note completes the picture: Katadyn's newer BeFree AC, built around the same EZ-Clean Membrane with an added replaceable activated carbon element, has taken the original's shelf spot at major US retailers, where REI lists the AC 1.0L at $52.95, a retailer price checked in November 2026. The carbon element addresses taste; the virus exclusion is unchanged.
GRAYL GeoPress: the grid's one purifier bottle, priced like it
The GeoPress is a 24-ounce bottle that works like a press: fill the outer cup, push the inner press down, and 24 ounces of water are treated in about 8 seconds, a rate GRAYL states as 5 liters per minute in batch form. It weighs 15.9 ounces, by far the heaviest product in this grid, and it is the only bottle here whose maker claims the full pathogen set: 99.99 percent of viruses, 99.9999 percent of bacteria, 99.9 percent of protozoan cysts, with particulates filtered and the activated carbon adsorbing many chemicals, including PFAS and VOCs, plus pesticides, herbicides, heavy metals, flavors, and odors. GRAYL states the bottle was independently tested to meet or exceed NSF/ANSI protocols 42 and 53 and meets the EPA's guide standard for microbiological water purifiers, and it backs the bottle with a 10-year warranty. GRAYL's store sells it at $89.95, below the $99.95 list price shown at retailers, and the grid uses the maker's price.
The purifier tier's cost is in the cartridge, not the bottle. A cartridge is rated for 350 cycles, 65 gallons, so the first cartridge's water costs about $1.38 per gallon and a $29.95 replacement cartridge brings that to about 46 cents per gallon, roughly twenty times the LifeStraw straw's rated cost and multiples of every membrane filter here. That is the honest price of virus removal in a bottle, and it comes with GRAYL's own boundary lines, which this page prints because GRAYL prints them: the cartridge is not designed for industrial disasters, coal ash spills, very high lead levels, mercury, nuclear disasters, high tannin concentrations, or toxic blue-green algae, and it is not for salty or brackish water. An unopened cartridge stores for up to 10 years by GRAYL's account; once in use, the three-year clock and the 25-second press-time signal govern.
Katadyn Micropur MP1: the chemical tier
Micropur MP1 is the grid's second virus answer, and it is not a filter at all. Each foil-sealed tablet releases chlorine dioxide and treats 1 liter of water; a pack holds 30 tablets, about $18.95 at US retailers, checked in November 2026, and the tablets carry a 5-year shelf life. Katadyn describes MP1 as the only product of its kind EPA-registered as a microbiological water purifier. Its directions are a ladder of wait times, stated here as Katadyn states them: 15 minutes for viruses and bacteria in all water; 30 minutes for Giardia and Cryptosporidium in normal water, 60 degrees F and clear; and 4 hours for Cryptosporidium in worst-case water, 39 degrees F, very dirty, and slightly acidic. The ladder is the product: the worse the water, the longer the chemistry needs, and the worst case is a four-hour wait for a liter.
Two limits define the tier. A tablet removes nothing: silt, chemicals, metals, and salt are all still in the water afterward, so cloudy water has to be settled or pre-filtered before the tablet goes in, and chemically contaminated water is outside this product entirely. And the Cryptosporidium direction above is Katadyn's, printed next to the CDC's general caution from the limits section: chemical disinfectants may not kill parasites including Cryptosporidium, and do not work as well as boiling against them. This page does not average those two statements into a third one. What the tier is genuinely for is the gap the CDC's sequence names: a membrane filter plus a disinfectant covers viruses, and a 30-tablet pack does that for 30 liters at about 63 cents a liter while weighing almost nothing and keeping for five years. As a sole method for a household, the arithmetic closes the question: 30 liters is about 7.9 gallons, roughly two days of drinking water for a household of four at a gallon per person per day, the planning figure our storage guide uses.
Cost per gallon, and what the ratings hide
The arithmetic behind the grid, shown in the open. LifeStraw straw: $24.95 divided by 1,000 rated gallons is about 2.5 cents per gallon. Sawyer MINI: $28.99 divided by 100,000 rated gallons is about 0.03 cents. Sawyer Squeeze: $45.99 divided by the 100,000-gallon figure from Sawyer's bundle pages is about 0.05 cents, with the product page's silence on a rating kept in view. LifeStraw Squeeze: $43.95 divided by 500 is about 8.8 cents, and $17.95 divided by 500 is about 3.6 cents on replacement membranes. Katadyn BeFree: $44.95 divided by 264 is about 17 cents, and $29.95 divided by 264 is about 11 cents on replacement cartridges. GRAYL GeoPress: $89.95 divided by 65 is about $1.38, and $29.95 divided by 65 is about 46 cents on replacement cartridges. Micropur MP1: about $18.95 divided by 30 liters is about 63 cents per liter, and 30 liters is about 7.9 gallons, so about $2.39 per gallon. Virus coverage, where it exists in this grid, costs about 46 cents to $2.39 per gallon. Bacteria and protozoa coverage costs between a fraction of a cent and 17 cents per rated gallon. That gap, not any single product, is the category's price structure.
The ratings also hide their own timescales. At a gallon a day, 100,000 gallons is about 274 years of drinking water; no pouch, seal, or owner keeps a filter that long, and one freeze after first use can end a Sawyer years before throughput does. The shorter ratings are the ones that can actually arrive: 1,000 gallons at a gallon a day is about 2.7 years, 500 gallons about 1.4 years, the BeFree's 264 gallons about 9 months, and a GeoPress cartridge's 65 gallons about 2 months. Read that way, the grid sorts itself: the Sawyers are effectively lifetime filters whose real limits are freezing, pouch wear, and backflushing discipline; the LifeStraws and the BeFree are consumables with honest clocks; and the purifier tier, the GeoPress cartridge and the Micropur pack, is priced per gallon like the short-lived product it is.
Questions
Do filter straws remove viruses?
No. The CDC states that portable filters will not remove viruses, and the makers of the straws and squeeze filters in this grid state the same exclusion for their own products, in LifeStraw's FAQs and on Sawyer's Duo page. Viruses pass through the 0.1 and 0.2 micron membranes these products use. The virus answers in this grid are the GRAYL GeoPress purifier bottle and chlorine dioxide tablets, and the CDC's method covers the rest: filter first, then disinfect, or boil.
Can a filter straw fill a water bottle or a pot?
No. A straw treats water only while you drink through it, at the source. The squeeze formats, the two Sawyers, the LifeStraw squeeze bottle, and the Katadyn BeFree, can push treated water into a bottle or a pot, and the GeoPress produces a 24-ounce bottle of treated water per press. If the job is filling anything, the straw is the wrong format regardless of brand.
What happens if my filter freezes?
Per the makers: replace it. Sawyer's warranty page says a filter that froze after wetting should be replaced because there is no way to know whether the fibers were damaged, the test costs more than the filter, and there is no warranty for a frozen filter. Katadyn's BeFree manual warns that a frozen membrane can lead to bypass and illness. A filter that has never been wetted is unharmed by freezing, per Sawyer. LifeStraw's product pages for the Peak straw and squeeze bottle, checked in November 2026, state no freeze position; the two makers who do state one both say the same thing.
How long will a Sawyer filter actually last?
Sawyer's warranty page rates the MINI line at up to 100,000 gallons, and its Squeeze carries a lifetime limited warranty on the filter itself with no gallon figure published on its product page. Both figures assume backflushing with the included syringe as flow slows; Sawyer credits backwashing with restoring up to 98.5 percent of flow. In practice the ends that arrive first are the ones Sawyer itself names: a freeze after wetting, which ends the filter outright, and wear to the pouches and accessories, which the warranty does not cover.
Do any portable filters remove lead or chemicals?
The membrane filters do not; LifeStraw and Sawyer both say so for their own products. The GRAYL GeoPress is the partial exception: GRAYL states its activated carbon adsorbs many chemicals, including PFAS and VOCs, plus pesticides, herbicides, and heavy metals, and GRAYL itself excludes very high lead levels, mercury, and industrial contamination. For water with known chemical contamination, the CDC's line governs the whole grid: boiling and disinfecting do not make chemically contaminated water safe.
What should I use during a boil-water advisory?
Boil the water, per the CDC: a rolling boil for 1 minute, or 3 minutes above 6,500 feet, is the best way to kill germs in water. If boiling is not possible, the CDC's sequence is to filter the water and then add a chemical disinfectant such as chlorine dioxide, which kills viruses and bacteria the filter leaves behind; the CDC cautions that disinfectants may not kill Cryptosporidium and Giardia and do not work as well as boiling against them. Follow the advisory's own instructions where they differ.
Can I use any of these with saltwater?
No. LifeStraw states its straw does not work in saltwater or brackish water, Sawyer states its squeeze filters do not remove salt, and GRAYL instructs users to avoid salty or brackish water. None of the products in this grid desalinates.